All bets off on delivery of farm worker hearing decision Saturday, May 24, 2008 by SUSAN MANN Stan Raper, a spokesperson for the United Food and Commercial Workers Union Canada (UFCW), calls the appeal a “landmark.” The union filed the appeal after an Ontario Superior Court judge rejected its claim two years ago that the Agricultural Employees Protection Act was unconstitutional. The Ontario Attorney General argued against the appeal, heard on Wednesday and Thursday. The Ontario Federation of Agriculture had intervener status at the hearing. Raper says that a question posed by one of the three judges from Ontario’s Appeal Court during the hearing indicates the judges favour striking down the current Agricultural Employees Protection Act. The judge had queried how long it would take to implement a new agricultural labour relations law (12 months was the response). The judges could potentially order the Ontario government to establish a new law enabling farm workers to join unions and bargain collectively. Ken Forth, chair of the agricultural industry’s Labour Issues Coordinating Committee, disagrees with UFCW’s assessment. He was at this week's hearing in Toronto and he’s been to several similar hearings. He says in his experience, judges have never indicated during a hearing what their decision will be. Forth didn’t attach any significance to that particular question, noting it was just one of hundreds the judges asked. Judges “ask questions because they don’t want to do a lot of presuming. They want to know the facts.” The farm employer’s perspective was the same as always, Forth notes. “We’re different than factories. We have a unique industry that has to do with living organisms, weather and all that kind of stuff that isn’t necessarily there in the industrial workplace.” Forth was pleased with how the farm employer side was presented. “Our people gave a clear view of agriculture.” The issues raised by UFCW Canada in this case were the same as they were 10 years ago, he notes. Raper’s also proposing two recent Supreme Court of Canada rulings on union issues in other provinces have made it clear farm workers have the right to form unions and bargain collectively under Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms. One decision from 2001 involved agricultural workers in Ontario. It ruled “an agricultural worker is entitled to the freedom of association, whether they’re on a family farm or a corporate farm.” The other, in 2007, involved hospital workers from British Columbia. Both decisions leave little leeway for any court in any province to make a decision other than farm workers have the right to form unions and bargain collectively, Raper says. The two sides also had differing opinions on when the decision would be handed down. Raper says the judges “indicated they would be making a fairly quick decision.” Normally decisions can take up to six months “but our lawyer indicated to us that it would probably be within a two-month time frame.” Forth says the judges didn’t say anything about how long it would take for a decision. Their lawyers told him the courts are currently busy and recent decisions have taken three to four months. Forth believes the length of time will depend on if all the judges interpret the issues in the same way. “If every one of them sees it exactly the same way, maybe it will be faster.” According to a UFCW news release, the appeal was made on behalf of three employees at the Kingsville-based Rol-Land Farms mushroom operation. In 2003, workers at Rol-Land had voted to join the union. The UFCW claims the provisions under the Ontario’s Agricultural Employees Protection Act prevented a union certificate from being issued. BF Farm net income gets a boost Groups warm to labelling proposal
Sowing Solutions--Guelph’s Agri-Food Research Gets Federal Spotlight Friday, October 3, 2025 The University of Guelph welcomed two prominent federal representatives for a day of engagement and discovery on Friday, October 3rd. Dominique O’Rourke, Member of Parliament for Guelph, hosted the Honourable Heath MacDonald, Minister of Agriculture and Agri-Food, for a comprehensive tour... Read this article online
Downtown Diner Delivers a Taste of Canadian Farming to Ottawa Friday, October 3, 2025 This week, the heart of Canada’s capital was filled with the sights, sounds, and flavors of Canadian agriculture as Sparks Street played host to the Downtown Diner, a pop-up event celebrating Canadian food and the farmers who make it possible. At the center of the conversation was... Read this article online
Poll Reveals Mixed Public Sentiment on BC Ostrich Cull Decision Thursday, October 2, 2025 Farms.com poll shows divided opinions among Canadian farmers on the Supreme Court’s decision to halt the ostrich cull. A recent poll conducted on Farms.com's X account @OntAg aimed to capture Canadian farmers' views on the Supreme Court’s decision to halt the ostrich cull in British... Read this article online
Effective Strategies for Corn Soybean and Wheat Thursday, October 2, 2025 As reported on the OMAFRA website fieldcropnews.com, effective crop residue management in corn, soybean, and wheat fields is key to profitability and long-term soil health. It begins at harvest, with combines and headers set correctly to size and spread residue evenly across the... Read this article online
New Ontario agrobotics challenge seeking high school submissions Thursday, October 2, 2025 A new competition for Ontario high school students is looking for innovative ways to solve challenges in the ag sector. The AgRobotics Ontario Challenge launched at the end of September. The competition is a collaboration between the Western Fair District, the Ontario Council for... Read this article online