Search
Better Farming OntarioBetter PorkBetter Farming Prairies

Better Farming Ontario Featured Articles

Better Farming Ontario magazine is published 11 times per year. After each edition is published, we share featured articles online.


Exemption or subsidy?

Thursday, January 28, 2016

by BETTER FARMING STAFF

Dianne Saxe, the new environmental commissioner of Ontario, says her remarks published earlier this month and widely regarded in rural Ontario as an attack on a tax exemption on coloured diesel fuel for agriculture, were reported inaccurately.

A column published in the National Post on Jan. 12 “was not accurate. It’s not what I said,” Saxe said in an interview on Friday.

She says her comments were in response to a question about what she learned when she was at the international climate change conference in Paris in December. “One of the big messages that the world governments agreed on in Paris is that fossil fuel subsidies prevent us from having a level playing field. (The National Post writer) asked me if we had any in Ontario,” and she mentioned the coloured diesel exemption.

Farm leaders such as Ontario Federation of Agriculture president Don McCabe have forcefully argued that the exemption from the road tax of which Saxe speaks is not a subsidy. It’s an exemption for farm machinery fuel from a tax that is in place to support road maintenance. The coloured fuel can also be used to fuel construction machinery and diesel engines that run generators.

Saxe stands by her use of the term ‘subsidy,’ which she attributes to the OECD (Organization of Economically Developed Countries) definition.

“By the international definition, (of a subsidy) a change in a rate of tax is a subsidy,” Saxe asserts. “It is not a moral judgement.”

The OECD says there are $1 trillion worth of subsidies worldwide applied to produce and use fossil fuels.

Saxe says according to the Ontario Ministry of Finance, the tax exemption on coloured diesel costs the province $215 million in revenue annually and agriculture benefits by $18 million.

“Two hundred and fifteen million dollars is a lot of money. Is the best way to support farming to give the most money to the people who use the most fossil fuels and the least money to the people who use the least fossil?” she says. “It’s possible there are better ways. It’s 87 per cent not about farming anyway.”

She doubts that the “fossil subsidies” will go away easily. “You don’t get to a trillion dollars in subsidies over the years without there being lots of political support for the subsidies … Our Prime Minister is committed to having this conversation. This is a conversation the whole world is having.”

“Governments around the world now have to ask the question about all the subsidies that they have for fossil fuels. Why do we have it, could we do better?”

In another recent interview on TVO (TV Ontario), Saxe had said that the previous environmental commissioner’s office had put forward the plan that the province adopted as its controversial plan to reduce neonicotinoid use.

“The environmental commissioner’s office is absolutely committed to making recommendations based on good science,” Saxe said Friday. She says she was “not involved” in “the specifics of the neonic report,” which was prepared when former commissioner Gord Miller was in charge.

“I haven’t been briefed on it yet so I can’t make any comment.”

Saxe says the commissioner’s central function is to be the guardian of the province’s Environmental Bill of Rights and to monitor, evaluate and report to the Legislature and to the public on government progress towards its targets on energy conservation, environmental protection and climate. Saxe adds there is a statutory requirement to produce at least one report annually on each of those three areas and there may be more reports as well. But don’t expect her to weigh in on every environmental issue. There are “lots and lots of issues” that the commission doesn’t have time to touch.

Saxe says it’s wrong to say the commissioner is appointed by the current government. “We are appointed unanimously by the three parties.” A representative from each party and the speaker do the selection and it has to be unanimous. “My duty is not to the government; it is to the Legislature and to all of the MPPs.

“We want to be as helpful to the MPPs as we can.”

Saxe expects to tour southwestern Ontario with OFA president McCabe in February.  She says visiting greenhouses and farms is familiar territory even though the law practice she just gave up to be environmental commissioner was located in downtown Toronto.  “It is mostly the type of operations I worked for when I was private practice.” BF

Current Issue

October 2024

Better Farming Magazine

Farms.com Breaking News

Getting your swine barns ready for the cold weather

Saturday, October 5, 2024

As the cold weather approaches, swine producers can perform barn maintenance checks now to help ensure a healthy environment for the fall and winter seasons. Mark Oberreuter, a System Design Engineer for AP (Automated Products, an AGCO company), recommended the following checklist... Read this article online

Meristem unveils new liquid BIO-CAPSULE technology

Friday, October 4, 2024

Byline: Denise Faguy Meristem Crop Performance has unveiled its new patent-pending LIQUID BIO-CAPSULE TECHNOLOGY, promising significant advantages for crops and farmers alike. This innovative delivery system aims to enhance the effectiveness of microbial products while ensuring they... Read this article online

FeedFlo makes it easier

Thursday, October 3, 2024

FeedFlo is a Winnipeg, Manitoba-headquartered company that offers what it says is the world’s only on-pipe feed sensor. The same-named on-pipe feed sensor, , tells operators exactly how much feed is being delivered to the animals so one can be sure that every pig in the barn is well... Read this article online

Who’s ready for advanced ag leadership?

Thursday, October 3, 2024

The () is now accepting applications for , which begins in September 2025. During the executive leadership program, up to 30 individuals will embark on a personal journey to realize their potential while exploring agriculture, food, and rural economic development from the local to... Read this article online

Ontario Farms Fill Your Thanksgiving Table

Thursday, October 3, 2024

Fresh Local Produce Stars in Ontario’s Fall Festivities Ontario’s farms are bustling with activity, providing an abundance of fresh produce just in time for Thanksgiving. This season, take the opportunity to immerse yourself in the local flavour and tradition that define Ontario’s... Read this article online

BF logo

It's farming. And it's better.

 

a Farms.com Company

Subscriptions

Subscriber inquiries, change of address, or USA and international orders, please email: subscriptions@betterfarming.com or call 888-248-4893 x 281.


Article Ideas & Media Releases

Have a story idea or media release? If you want coverage of an ag issue, trend, or company news, please email us.

Follow us on Social Media

 

Sign up to a Farms.com Newsletter

 

DisclaimerPrivacy Policy2024 ©AgMedia Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Back To Top