by SUSAN MANN
Shropshire sheep farmer Montana Jones is exploring legal options to stop Canadian Food Inspection Agency officials from destroying part of her heritage breed flock as early as January.
Forty-four animals on the Hastings-area farm in Northumberland County are considered by the agency to be at high risk of being infected with scrapie and are slated to be destroyed sometime in the new year. Lisa Gauthier, CFIA media relations officer, says by email a specific date hasn’t been set yet.
“When scrapie is suspected or confirmed on a farm, infected animals, as well as those deemed to be at risk of the disease, are humanely destroyed and disposed of,” she says, noting the CFIA’s disease control measures are based on international science-based standards.
But Jones says there’s nothing humane about the destruction of her sheep. After killing the sheep and removing their heads for brain tissue testing, CFIA officials “leave them to me to bury my own dead sheep.”
A fatal disease
Scrapie is a fatal disease affecting the central nervous system of sheep and goats. There isn’t a treatment or vaccine currently available for the disease. It’s a transmissible spongiform encephalopathy (TSE). Other TSE’s are bovine spongiform encephalopathy in cattle and chronic wasting disease in deer and elk.
The disease isn’t a human health risk but it does affect the productivity of sheep. Scrapie is a federally reportable disease in Canada meaning all suspected cases must be reported to the CFIA.
Jennifer MacTavish, executive director with the Canadian Sheep Federation, says she can’t comment specifically about Jones’ case because they haven’t been contacted by Jones. All of the information they have about the situation was obtained through news reports. “We have reached out to the producer but have not heard from them.”
But “we’re always concerned about cases of scrapie in Canada,” she says, noting the disease impacts the country’s ability to trade.
The CFIA’s Gauthier says the agency has the endorsement and encouragement of the national sheep and goat industries to pursue total scrapie eradication in Canada.
Shropshires less resistant to the disease
The sheep targeted for destruction on Jones’ farm have a genotype that is considered less resistant to scrapie but that doesn’t necessarily mean the animals would ever get the disease. Her flock was flagged after scrapie was found in a sheep in Alberta that originated from her farm more than five years ago. But Jones’ entire herd has tested negative for the disease using a test that has an 85 per cent accuracy rate.
Fifty sheep on the Alberta farm where the disease was found were destroyed recently.
In the 12 years since Jones has been breeding Shropshires, none of the sheep living on her farm has ever had scrapie and she’s never seen any symptoms of the disease in her flock.
Farm quarantined
Jones’ farm has been quarantined for the past 18 months meaning animals can be sold for meat but she can’t sell the registered Shropshires as breeding stock. There is compensation for the sheep ordered destroyed but the CFIA doesn’t have anything for farmers under quarantine. Jones hasn’t been able to earn money from selling her breeding stock and it was that income she used to pay for her infrastructure plus the animals’ hay and grain.
There are a total of 75 sheep on the farm with some of them being very small male market lambs destined for meat. If the CFIA proceeds with its plans to kill the 44 sheep, Jones says it doesn’t mean she’ll have “all these sheep left.” In fact, she’ll only have 14 females of her breeding stock remaining.
And the breed, which is close to extinction in Canada, would take a huge hit with only 107 registered breeding females, 16 rams and 38 ewe lambs left.
Jones says her animals are part of a “heritage breed flock with really rare genetics and I can’t turn around and replace them with commercial sheep.”
Jones, CFIA negotiating
Jones’ proposal to the CFIA is to do a five-year survey, quarantine and monitoring program so the agency gets the heads for testing of all the farm’s sheep that die or go to an abattoir for meat. And no sheep will leave the “property except for that.” She’d also want to continue breeding “so I’m still increasing the numbers of the breed and we’ll go from there.”
In turn, the CFIA has proposed that:
• Jones sign a declaration of an infected place (currently her farm is considered a potential source of infection)
• The agency would euthanize her 12 rams
• Remaining sheep that were also identified by the agency for slaughter would be euthanized in two years
• Jones would have to pay for all testing as well as for cleaning and disinfecting
Jones says she has been given until New Year’s Eve to accept the CFIA proposal otherwise in January she would receive a firm date for when agency officials would kill her sheep. At that point, Jones says she’ll have a lawyer in place and possibly install an injunction.
Another option she’s considering is inviting hundreds of people including media crews on to her farm on the date the sheep will be killed. “Do you think they’d proceed with that with cameras rolling and things? I doubt it.”
Jones has launched a public campaign to save her sheep, including an online petition and requests for donations of money or hay at: shropshiresheep.org . In the week since the petition has been up, 1,800 people have signed. Through Twitter, people have suggested Jones hide her sheep from the CFIA but she responds she won’t.
They’re staying on her farm. “I can protect them better and do more for them here,” she says. BF
Comments
Thanks for running the story on my endangered Shropshire flock...just to clarify however...the photo pictured above is somewhat misleading—it is a photo of commercial FEEDLOT sheep..they are not Shropshires nor are they pasture-based as mine are. I raise mine naturally on grass.
*My goal is for CFIA and Agriculture Canada to implement an alternative course to the present, outdated scrapie protocol. My proposed rare heritage breed exemption for flocks would include on-farm monitoring, quarantine, surveillance and continued selective breeding to increase breed population, while still submitting the obexes of any dead sheep (that die naturally or at abattoir) for testing. This will be important not just for my flock, but to future flocks where this situation may arise.*
The pilot project CFIA currently proposes is not an option. With it, the sheep and genetics are still destroyed. CFIA has advised me I have until New Years Eve to apply for a pilot project that would mean I must:
• Declare my farm “infected” when it isn’t; CFIA considers my farm a "potential source of infection" to the Alberta case found, and CFIA is asking me to LIE and sign a "Declaration of Infected Place" that would give them the right to initiate activities which are not necessary as they might be on a premises where scrapie was actually found.
• Agree to let them destroy all my heritage rams NOW;
• Keep the QQ ewes for now and use an RR ram for 2 years’
THEN let them destroy all the QQ ewes anyway.
I asked why still destroy the ewes after 2 years when that time allows even more live testing and likely even more negative results?
So I will not agree to that...not agree to killing all my rare Miller line sons, not agree to kill the ewes in 2 years, and not agree to lie and say my farm is infected when it is NOT—CFIA has found no trace of scrapie.
There are also questions surrounding the possible misidentification of the Alberta ewe.
CFIA agrees the Alberta positive ewe may have contracted it some time after she left my Ontario farm. Her two offspring both tested negative for scrapie, despite the fact that one is actually a QQ.
Also to clarify, I have in fact emailed the Canadian Sheep Federation and numerous other assocaitions and organizations about this matter.
Would very much appreciate signatures to the petition to Ag Canada and CFIA to stop and modify their protocol to reflect and protect our heritage breeds, especially when no other humans or animals are at risk. Thanks very much http://ShropshireSheep.org
Montana Jones
Post new comment