By SUSAN MANN
About 1,000 tobacco quota holders received a payment under a program designed to address declining product demand but more than half of them weren’t active tobacco producers, according to the fall auditor general’s report.
In 2008 there were 446 active tobacco producers, while in 2009 there were 118 and in 2010 there were 251, it says in the report by John Wiersema, interim auditor general, released Tuesday.
The Ontario Flue-Cured Tobacco Growers’ Marketing Board, which delivered the Tobacco Transition Program to producers on behalf of Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, paid out a total of $284 million by May 2009. Tobacco quota holders who agreed to leave the industry were paid $1.05 per pound for quota. The Ontario government didn’t contribute funds to the program.
But some farmers who took money to leave the industry then switched their land and equipment to relatives who continued growing tobacco under the new licensing system.
The transition program was created to address the severe decline in demand for flue-cured tobacco from southern Ontario, Canada’s main region for flue-cured tobacco production. Wiersema’s audit revealed two of the three program objectives were achieved while the third objective, which was to facilitate the transition of tobacco producers out of the industry “was not as far advanced,” the report says.
Eliminating the tobacco quota system and improving the viability of remaining and future tobacco farmers were achieved under the program.
Wiersema says the federal agriculture department had to deliver the program within a short time frame and didn’t first conduct a thorough risk analysis. The agreement to implement the program didn’t provide clear terms and conditions to ensure recipients wouldn’t enter into business arrangements that would undermine the intent of the program.
In addition, the department changed its interpretation of what was and wasn’t allowed under the agreement a number of times resulting in confusion for producers. The department was successful in controlling some but not all of the business arrangements that would compromise the program’s intent.
In an email, Agriculture Canada says it is working with the Ontario tobacco board to ensure that they fully implement the recommendations of external audits that were done on behalf of the department. BF
Comments
DELHI, Ontario, August 1, 2008 � The Government of Canada is providing more than $300 million to Ontario�s flue-cured tobacco producers, including $286 million for a Tobacco Transition Program to help them exit the tobacco industry, and $15 million for community development initiatives.
The announcement was made today by the Honourable Gerry Ritz, Federal Agriculture Minister, at the Delhi Tobacco Exchange Auction, joined by the Honourable Diane Finley, Minister of Citizenship and Immigration and MP for Haldimand-Norfolk, and Joe Preston, MP for Elgin-Middlesex-London.
"Minister Finley has been a tireless proponent of an exit package for tobacco farmers," said Minister Ritz. "As such, the Conservative government has been committed to finding a responsible solution. I�ve said it before and I will say it again: the Conservative government is committed to putting farmers first."
The Tobacco Transition Program will provide transition and exit assistance to producers interested in exiting the sector. Payments will be based on proposals by the Ontario Flue-Cured Tobacco Growers� Marketing Board and accepted by the government. The program will provide federal funding of $1.05 per pound per quota, which is consistent with the federal portion of the Board�s latest request.
"Through our work with the Ontario Flue-Cured Tobacco Growers� Marketing Board our government has produced real results and shown our commitment to farmers," said Minister Finley. "Tobacco producers and their families will be able to bring closure to what has been a very stressful time. This program is available to help producers exit the industry, transition to other crops, or find new opportunities outside agriculture."
Post new comment