COOL faces court challenge Tuesday, July 9, 2013 by SUSAN MANN American and Canadian farming industry groups have stepped up their challenge of the United States’ amended mandatory County of Origin Labelling law by filing a lawsuit to block its implementation. The lawsuit was filed Monday in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia. Two Canadian livestock groups have joined – the Canadian Pork Council and the Canadian Cattlemen’s Association. The other groups launching the lawsuit are: the American Association of Meat Processors, American Meat Institute, National Cattlemen’s Beef Association, National Pork Producers Council, North American Meat Association and Southwest Meat Association. In a July 9 joint press release, the groups allege the United States Department of Agriculture’s May 23 amendments to the Country of Origin Labelling law violate the American Constitution and the Agriculture Marketing Act. The law is also arbitrary and capricious, the groups say. None of the allegations have been proven in court. John Masswohl, Canadian Cattlemen’s director of government and international relations, says the lawsuit has two aspects. The first is a request for a temporary injunction to stop the May 23 amendments to COOL from being implemented. Even though the amendments became final on May 23, the USDA says it’s not enforcing them for the first six months, he notes. The request is for the temporary injunction to be in place until the underlying constitutional challenge to the “whole COOL program can be heard,” he says. The temporary injunction could be installed within six months while the constitutional challenge could take years to complete. “It’s unfortunate that it had to come to this because our objective was not to get rid of COOL altogether,” he says. “Our objective was for a very surgical amendment that would eliminate the discrimination against imported meat and livestock while keeping the county of origin labelling program.” But now if the constitutional challenge is successful, the entire COOL program could be struck down. The USDA’s amendments to COOL became final on May 23. They were implemented after the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruled in response to a Canadian and Mexican complaint that the existing COOL requirements violate the Americans’ WTO obligations. Last month, the Canadian federal government released a list of U.S. commodities it could target for retaliation. The federal government is seeking retaliatory compensation of about $1.1 billion annually after the WTO challenge of the May 23 COOL amendments is completed. The WTO challenge will continue independently of the industry groups’ lawsuit. Gary Stordy, Canadian Pork Council public relations manager, says the lawsuit is one of three avenues the council is using to try to deal with COOL. “We wanted to be part of this process so we can follow and be engaged with this legal dispute.” Another reason the Pork Council joined was to acknowledge the Canadian and American pork industries are integrated. “We have colleagues within the meat and livestock industry in the States bringing forward this challenge and we felt that it was important to participate,” he says. He says the other two avenues the Pork Council has to deal with COOL are: the Canadian government process to launch a WTO challenge of the American government’s May 23 amendments; and advocacy, where pork council representatives discuss the situation with American legislators. The Canadian Cattlemen’s says in its July 9 press release it has spent more than $2 million to cover legal and advocacy expenses so far to fight COOL. In their July 9 joint press release, the American and Canadian groups say the USDA’s May 23 rules violate the American Constitution “by compelling speech in the form of costly and detailed labels on meat products that do not directly advance a government interest.” In addition, the groups say the COOL rules are arbitrary and capricious because they impose vast burdens on the industry with “little or no countervailing effect.” The groups assert that because the labels don’t provide a food safety or health benefit yet impose costs, the government can’t require they be used. The groups also claim the new rules violate the Agriculture Marketing Act because they exceed the authority granted to the USDA in the 2008 Farm Bill. The Pork Council says in its Tuesday press release there have been a 41 per cent decline in Canadian live swine exports to the United States since mandatory country of origin labelling was implemented in 2008 and a 46 per cent decrease in beef cattle exports. Damages to the Canadian livestock sector have exceeded $1 billion per year since 2008 due to price declines, lost sales and added costs. That damage figure doesn’t include additional damage caused by the May 23 amendments to COOL. The Canadian livestock groups say the new rule the USDA implemented May 23 is even more onerous than the previous one. Stordy says the Pork Council is now tracking the additional damage caused by the new rules. Masswohl says the Canadian Cattlemen’s will also be updating its damage figure. BF Conservative MPPs want addition to proposed local food act: a tax credit for farmers who donate food DFO funds two faculty positions at the University of Guelph
Ontario’s most problematic weed -- Canada Fleabane Cuts Corn and Soybean Yields Wednesday, September 17, 2025 At the , Dr. Peter Sikkema of the University of Guelph highlighted the persistent challenge of Canada fleabane, one of Ontario’s most problematic weeds. Once easily controlled with glyphosate, the weed has now developed resistance not only to glyphosate but also to multiple herbicide... Read this article online
Augusta Van Muyen selected as the 67th Grape King Wednesday, September 17, 2025 Grape Growers of Ontario and Farm Credit Canada have announced that Lincoln vineyard manager Augusta Van Muyen has been chosen by her peers as the . Currently, the vineyard manager at Tawse Winery, Van Muyen, followed a path to success that took her across Ontario and the world.... Read this article online
Grain Growers of Canada calls on Carney to Prioritize Upgrades to the Port of Vancouver Wednesday, September 17, 2025 Grain Growers of Canada (GGC) is calling on the federal government to urgently prioritize major upgrades to the Port of Vancouver and its connecting rail infrastructure. The organization warns that without these improvements, Canada’s economic growth and global trade reliability are at... Read this article online
Strategies to Optimize Market Returns in Ontario Monday, September 15, 2025 Berkley Fedorchuk, grain marketing specialist with Hensall Co-op in Southwestern Ontario, recently shared insights into the current corn market and strategies for forward marketing during his presentation at the . With a focus on the Ontario and Eastern Canadian grain sectors,... Read this article online
From Plows to Plates - The 2025 International Plowing Match Returns to Niagara Friday, September 12, 2025 For the first time since 1926, the International Plowing Match & Rural Expo (IPM) is returning to the Niagara Region September 16 to 20. Set to take place in West Lincoln, the 106th edition of this iconic event will run under the theme “From our Farm to your Table,” celebrating... Read this article online